Proposition XLV: Non-Constructibility (Inscibilitas) of the Heptagon¶
Original GEOMETOR English translation from Johannes Kepler’s Harmonices Mundi Liber I, Propositio XLV (Linz, 1619, pp. 41–46; Frisch V, pp. 119–125).
Proposition XLV (*Enunciation*): The side of the Regular Heptagon (*Septangulum*, :g:`HEPT7`), and every figure whose number of sides is a prime number beyond five (such as 7, 11, 13, 17?, 19) or a multiple of nine, lacks geometric knowability and cannot be constructed from the diameter by Euclidean plane geometry.
For consider the heptagonal triangle H1H2H4 inscribed in cHEPT (right panel above), bounded by three unequal chords: the heptagon side $s_1 = H_1 H_2$, the short diagonal $s_2 = H_1 H_3$ (diags2), and the long diagonal $s_3 = H_1 H_4$ (diags3). Unlike the pentagon—where only two chord species exist ($s_5$ and $d_5$), locking their ratio immediately into a quadratic equation $x^2 - x - 1 = 0$ solvable by a circle and straight line—the heptagon entangles three chord species simultaneously!
My ingenious friend Jost Bürgi (Justus Byrgius) has indeed exhibited an algebraic (Cossic) equation relating the chord of one-seventh of the circumference to the radius:
$$y^6 - 7y^4 + 14y^2 - 7 = 0 \qquad \Longleftrightarrow \qquad x^3 + x^2 - 2x - 1 = 0 \quad \left(x = 2\cos\frac{2\pi}{7}\right).$$
Yet I reply that algebraic root-reckoning is not Euclidean geometric determination! First, this equation climbs to the cubic (third) solid degree in $x$ (or sixth in $y$), which no intersection of straight lines and circles in a plane can cut off; second, the very same algebraic equation admits three distinct real roots simultaneously—answering indifferently to the convex heptagon chord $\frac{1}{7}$, the first star heptagram $\frac{2}{7}$, and the second star heptagram $\frac{3}{7}$—without singling out one magnitude from the diameter by finite geometric necessity:
“Therefore no Regular Heptagon has ever been constructed by anyone knowingly, willingly, and acting from deliberate geometrical purpose; nor **can* it be constructed from deliberate purpose—though by blind chance its length might be stumbled upon, without anyone ever knowing whether it has been!”*
Thus the Creator excluded the heptagon, enneagon ($n = 9$), hendecagon ($n = 11$), and their kin from the archetypal council of cosmic harmonies.