§ 49: § 49: Distances from Circumcenter K to S, S’, S’’, S’’’ — Euler (1765) & Fuß (1797) — Notes

Historical, Philological & Symbolic Commentary

GEOMETOR Commentary & Symbolic Notes

1. Discovery & Diagnosis of Feuerbach’s § 51 / § 52 / § 60 Sign-Substitution Slip

When encoding every equation of Feuerbach (1822) §§ 49–60 in geometor.feuerbach.euler.prove_euler_1765_identities() over \(\mathbb{Q}(a, b, c)\) in sympy, a striking philological fact emerged on pages 35, 36, and 40–41:

  • In § 51 (p. 35), Feuerbach proves directly from coordinates the 100% exact incenter quadrance

    \[\overline{OS}^2 = 2r^2 - 2\rho R.\]
  • Immediately below on p. 35, he applies his customary substitution \((a, b, c) \mapsto (-a, b, c)\) to write:

    \[\overline{OS^{(k)}}^2 \stackrel{\text{1822 text}}{=} 2r^{(k)2} + 2\rho R \qquad \text{(printed slip!)}.\]
  • Why this fails algebraically: By § 24 (p. 18) and \(R = \frac{abc}{4\Delta}\),

    \[\rho R = \frac{(-a^2+b^2+c^2)(a^2-b^2+c^2)(a^2+b^2-c^2)}{64\Delta^2}.\]

    Under \(a \mapsto -a\) (holding \(+\Delta\) positive), both \(R\) and \(\rho\) reverse sign (\(R \mapsto -R\) and \(\rho \mapsto -\rho\)), so their product \(\rho R\) is strictly invariant! The true exact identities over \(\mathbb{Q}(a,b,c)\) are \(\overline{OS^{(k)}}^2 = 2r^{(k)2} - 2\rho R\), and the true sum is \(\sum \overline{OS_i}^2 = 16R(R - \rho)\).