An Easy Solution of Certain Very Difficult Geometric Problems

Solutio facilis problematum quorumdam geometricorum difficillimorum — Leonhard Euler (1765, Eneström E325)

First Edition (Latin, 1767): Novi Commentarii Academiae Scientiarum Imperialis Petropolitanae, Tom. XI pro Anno MDCCLXV, Petropoli: Typis Academiae Scientiarum, MDCCLXVII, pp. 103–123, Tab. II Fig. 1–9 (Opera Omnia, Ser. I, Vol. 26, pp. 139–157).
English Translation: Original folio-verified translation curated for the GEOMETOR Digital Scriptorium.
Synchronized 4-Track Codex: English · Latin · Summary · Notes, paired with exact symbolic verification in geometor.euler.

„Tum vero omnibus difficultatibus feliciter superatis insignes quaedam affectiones inter illa quatuor puncta se prodent, quarum cognitio in Geometria haud leuis momenti est censenda.“

“Moreover, once all difficulties have been happily overcome, certain remarkable properties among those four points reveal themselves, the knowledge of which must be judged of no small importance in Geometry.”

—Leonhard Euler, Solutio facilis, § 3 (p. 104)


Table of Contents

  • §§ 1–9 — The Four Classical Triangle Centers & Orthogonal Coordinates (pp. 103–107) (English · Latin · Summary · Notes)

    Enumeration of the four classical concurrency centers \(E = X(4)\) (orthocenter), \(F = X(2)\) (centroid), \(G = X(1)\) (incenter), and \(H = X(3)\) (circumcenter), formulation of the inverse determination problem, and derivation of their rational orthogonal coordinates on base \(AB = c\).

  • §§ 10–18 — Symmetric Polynomials, Six Mutual Quadrances & The Euler Line (pp. 107–114) (English · Latin · Summary · Notes)

    Change of variables to the elementary symmetric polynomials \(p = a+b+c\), \(q = ab+ac+bc\), \(r = abc\), symmetric Heron expansion \(16A^2 = -p^4 + 4p^2q - 8pr\), closed-form derivation of all six squared inter-center distances (Formulas I–VI), discovery of the Euler Line (\(FH = \tfrac{1}{2}EF\), \(EH = \tfrac{3}{2}EF\)), and the compatibility law \(4GH^2 + 2EG^2 = 3EF^2 + 6FG^2\).

  • §§ 19–24 — The Inverse Reconstruction Problem & Side-Length Cubic (pp. 114–118) (English · Latin · Summary · Notes)

    Reduction of the inverse problem (“given the four centers \(E, F, G, H\), construct the triangle”) to auxiliary invariants \(P = p^2\), \(Q = r/p\), \(R = r^2/(4A^2)\), exact cancellation of the quadratic term \(Q^2\) yielding rational \((P, q, Q)\), Viète’s cubic \(z^3 - pz^2 + qz - r = 0\), and the integer benchmark \((5, 6, 7) \implies z^3 - 18z^2 + 107z - 210 = 0\).

  • §§ 25–34 — Collinear Centers, Isosceles Degeneracy & Casus Irreducibilis (pp. 118–123) (English · Latin · Summary · Notes)

    Analysis of the degenerate case in which \(G\) lies on the Euler line \(EH\) (forcing an isosceles triangle with rational root \(z = c\)), the four positional regimes relative to midpoint \(I\), symmetric parameterization by \((e, f, k) = (EG, GH, EH)\), reality diorismos inequalities, and angle trisection in the casus irreducibilis.

Euler (1765/1767, E325): Four Classical Triangle Centers E, F, G, H and the Euler Line A B C a b S R E (X₄) F (X₂) G (X₁) H (X₃)
Euler (1765/1767, E325): Four Classical Triangle Centers E, F, G, H and the Euler Line A B C a b S R E (X₄) F (X₂) G (X₁) H (X₃)

Euler (1765) §§ 10–18 — Critical & Symbolic Notes

Visual inspection of the 1767 Novi Commentarii pages reveals four minor printing slips in the intermediate derivations, all of which Euler silently corrects in his summary table § 18 on p. 114:

Euler (1765/1767, E325): Four Classical Triangle Centers E, F, G, H and the Euler Line A B C a b S R E (X₄) F (X₂) G (X₁) H (X₃)

Euler (1765) §§ 10–18 — Summary

Symmetric Basis (§ 11): Because the mutual distances among \(E, F, G, H\) cannot privilege any side of \(\triangle ABC\), Euler introduces \(p = a+b+c\), \(q = ab+ac+bc\), \(r = abc\), rewriting Heron’s formula as \(16\mathcal{A}^2 = -p^4 + 4p^2q - 8pr\). Since \(R_{\text{circ}} = \frac{abc}{4\mathcal{A}} = \frac{r}{4\mathcal{A}}\) and \(r_{\text{in}} = \frac{2\mathcal{A}}{p}\), the ubiquitous quantity \(\frac{r^2}{16\mathcal{A}^2}\) is simply \(R_{\text{circ}}^2\), and \(\frac{r}{p} = 2R_{\text{circ}}r_{\text{in}}\).

Euler (1765) §§ 19–24 — Summary

Why the System Collapses to Rational Linear Equations (§§ 19–21): Introducing homogeneous dimension-2 invariants \(P = p^2\), \(Q = \frac{r}{p} = 2R_{\text{circ}}r_{\text{in}}\), and \(R = \frac{r^2}{4\mathcal{A}^2} = 4R_{\text{circ}}^2\) turns Equations I, II, III of § 21 into:

Euler (1765) §§ 25–34 — Critical & Symbolic Notes

In §§ 28–29 (pp. 119–120), Euler bisects the segment \(EH\) (\(= 2d\)) and classifies every isosceles triangle according as \(EG < d\) (Fig. 8, \(a > c\)) or \(EG > d\) (Fig. 9, \(a < c\)). Geometrically, the midpoint of \(EH\) is precisely Feuerbach’s nine-point center \(L = X(5)\). By Feuerbach’s Theorem (§ 57), \(LG = \tfrac{1}{2}R_{\text{circ}} - r_{\text{in}}\), which vanishes only when \(R_{\text{circ}} = 2r_{\text{in}}\) (the equilateral triangle). Since \(E, G, L, F, H\) all lie along the axis of symmetry of an isosceles triangle with \(EL = LH = d\), the non-vanishing distance \(LG > 0\) explains geometrically why Euler’s two regimes \(EG < d\) (\(a > c\), where \(G\) lies inside \(EL\)) and \(EG > d\) (\(a < c\), where \(G\) lies inside \(LF\)) are separated exclusively by the equilateral coalescence.

Euler (1765) §§ 25–34 — Summary

Isosceles Characterization of Euler-Line Collinearity (§§ 25–29): The incenter \(G = X(1)\) lies on the Euler Line \(EH\) if and only if \(\triangle ABC\) is isosceles (\(a = b\)). Setting \(EH = 2d\) around the midpoint of \(EH\) (namely the nine-point center \(L = X(5)\)!) and \(EG = d \mp e\):

Scholarly Apparatus