Unit 3 Summary: Ceva, Menelaus, Similitude & Anharmonic Projectivity

Mathematical Synthesis of Casey’s Book VI, Sections I–III & VI

1. Directed Ratios & Projective Duality Inside Euclidean Geometry

Unit 3 marks the transition in Casey’s Sequel from metric Euclidean geometry to projective invariants:

  • Ceva vs. Menelaus Duality: Both theorems evaluate the identical cyclic product $\frac{BD}{DC}\cdot\frac{CE}{EA}\cdot\frac{AF}{FB}$ on $\triangle ABC$: $+1$ characterizes concurrency of three lines (Ceva), while $-1$ characterizes collinearity of three points (Menelaus).

  • Homothecy & Monge’s Theorem: Two circles possess external and internal centres of similitude $S_e, S_i$ dividing $O_1 O_2$ harmonically in ratio $\pm r_1 : r_2$; Menelaus’s theorem immediately forces the six centres of similitude of three circles onto Monge’s four axes of similitude.

  • Complete Quadrilateral Harmonic Invariance: Pure linear incidence alone—without compass or metric measurement—constructs the fourth harmonic conjugate of three collinear points via the third diagonal $[EF]$ of a complete quadrilateral (0117.g1.svg).

  • Anharmonic Pencils on a Circle: Inscribed angle equality (Euclid III.21) makes the cross-ratio $P(ABCD)$ invariant on a circle, unlocking short synthetic proofs of Desargues’s Homology Theorem and Pascal’s Hexagrammum Mysticum.


2. Verified Exact Quadrilateral Ledger (geometor.casey.poles_polars)

Constructed in construct_complete_quadrilateral_harmonic() (0117.g1.svg):

Exact Rational Coordinates & Cross-Ratios of the Complete Quadrilateral

Projective Element

Incidence Definition

Exact Rational Value

Quadrangle Base Vertices

$A, B, C, D$

$(0, 0), \; (6, 0), \; (4, 2), \; (2, 3)$

Opposite Side Intersections

$E = [AB]\cap[CD], \; F = [AD]\cap[BC]$

$E = (8, 0), \; F = \left(\frac{12}{5}, \frac{18}{5}\right)$

Internal Diagonal Centre

$P = [AC]\cap[BD]$

$P = \left(\frac{18}{5}, \frac{9}{5}\right)$

Third Diagonal Harmonic Meets

$Q_a = [AC]\cap[EF], \; Q_b = [BD]\cap[EF]$

$Q_a = \left(\frac{9}{2}, \frac{9}{4}\right), \; Q_b = (-6, 9)$

Verified Cross-Ratios

$(A,C;P,Q_a), \; (B,D;P,Q_b), \; (E,F;Q_a,Q_b)$

$-1, \; -1, \; -1$