Book VI, Section VI: Theory of Anharmonic Section¶
SECTION VI.¶
THEORY OF ANHARMONIC SECTION.¶
Def.—A system of four collinear points $A, B, C, D$ make, as is known, six segments; these may be arranged in three pairs, each containing the four letters—thus,
$$ AB, CD; \quad BC, AD; \quad CA, BD. $$
Where the last letter in each couple is $D$, and the first
f. 0153 · p. 127segments in the three couples are respectively $AB, BC, CA$, exactly corresponding to the sides of a triangle $ABC$, taken in order. Now, if we take the rectangles formed by these three pairs of segments, the six quotients obtained by dividing each rectangle by the two remaining ones are called the six anharmonic ratios of the four points $A, B, C, D$. Thus these six functions are
$$ \frac{AB \cdot CD}{BC \cdot AD}, \qquad \frac{BC \cdot AD}{CA \cdot BD}, \qquad \frac{CA \cdot BD}{AB \cdot CD}; $$
and their reciprocals
$$ \frac{BC \cdot AD}{AB \cdot CD}, \qquad \frac{CA \cdot BD}{BC \cdot AD}, \qquad \frac{AB \cdot CD}{CA \cdot BD}. $$
It is usual to call any one of these six functions the anharmonic ratio of the four points $A, B, C, D$.
Prop. 1.—If $(O\,.\,ABCD)$ be a pencil of four rays passing through the four points $A, B, C, D$; and if through any of these points $B$ we draw a line parallel to a ray passing through any of the other points, and cutting the two remaining rays in the points $M, N$, the six anharmonic ratios of $A, B, C, D$ can be expressed in terms of the ratios of the segments $MB, BN, NM$.
Dem.—From similar triangles,
$$ \frac{MB}{OD} = \frac{AB}{AD}, $$
and
$$ \frac{OD}{BN} = \frac{CD}{BC}. $$
f. 0154 · p. 128Hence,
$$ \frac{MB}{BN} = \frac{AB \cdot CD}{BC \cdot AD}; $$
therefore
$$ MB : BN :: AB \cdot CD : BC \cdot AD. $$
Componendo—
$$ MN : BN :: AB \cdot CD + BC \cdot AD : BC \cdot AD; $$
$$ \therefore MN : BN :: AC \cdot BD : BC \cdot AD; $$
$$ \therefore MB : BN : NM :: AB \cdot CD : BC \cdot AD : CA \cdot BD. $$
Prop. 2.—If a pencil of four rays be cut by two transversals $ABCD, A'B'C'D'$, then any of the anharmonic ratios of the points $A, B, C, D$ is equal to the corresponding ratio for the points $A', B', C', D'$.
Dem.—Through the points $B, B'$ draw $MN, M'N'$ parallel to $OD$; then (Section I., Prop. 3) we have
$$ MB : BN :: M'B' : B'N'; $$
therefore
$$ \frac{AB \cdot CD}{BC \cdot AD} = \frac{A'B' \cdot C'D'}{B'C' \cdot A'D'}. $$
Cor. 1.—We may suppose the rays of the pencil produced through the vertex, and the transversal to cut any of the rays produced without altering the anharmonic ratio.
Def.—The anharmonic ratio of the four points on any transversal cutting a pencil being constant, it is called the anharmonic ratio of the pencil.
Cor. 2.—If two pencils have equal anharmonic ratios and a common vertex; and if three rays of one pencil be the production of three rays of the other, then the fourth ray of one is the production of the fourth ray of the other.
Cor. 3.—If two pencils have a common transversal, they are equal; that is, they have equal anharmonic ratios.
f. 0155 · p. 129Cor. 4.—If $A, B, C, D$ be four points in the circumference of a circle, and $E$ and $F$ any two other points also in the circumference, then the pencil $(E\,.\,ABCD) = (F\,.\,ABCD)$. This is evident, since the pencils have equal angles.
Cor. 5.—If through the middle point $O$ of any chord $AB$ of a circle two other chords $CE$ and $DF$ be drawn, and if the lines $ED$ and $CF$ joining their extremities intersect $AB$ in $G$ and $H$, then $OG = OH$.
Dem.—The pencil $(E\,.\,ADCB) = (F\,.\,ADCB)$; therefore the anharmonic ratio of the points $A, G, O, B =$ the anharmonic ratio of the points $A, O, H, B$; and since $AO = OB$, $OG = OH$.
Def.—The anharmonic ratio of the cyclic pencil $(E\,.\,ABCD)$ is called the anharmonic ratio of the four cyclic points $A, B, C, D$.
Prop. 3.—The anharmonic ratio of four concyclic points can be expressed in terms of the chords joining these four points.
Dem.—The anharmonic ratio of the pencil $(O\,.\,ABCD)$ is $AC \cdot BD : AB \cdot CD$; and this, by Prop. 9, Section IV., $= A'C' \cdot B'D' : A'B' \cdot C'D'$; but the pencil $(O\,.\,ABCD) =$ the pencil $(O\,.\,A'B'C'D') =$ the anharmonic ratio of the points $A', B', C', D'$. Hence the Proposition is proved.
Cor. 1.—The six functions formed, as in Def. 1, with the six chords joining the four concyclic points $A', B', C', D'$, are the six anharmonic ratios of these points.
Cor. 2.—If two triangles $CAB, C'A'B'$ be inscribed in a circle, any two sides, viz., one from each triangle, are divided equianharmonically by the four remaining sides. For, let the sides be $AB, A'B'$; then the pencils $(C\,.\,A'BAB'), (C'\,.\,A'BAB')$ are equal (Cor. 4, Prop. 2).
Prop. 4.—Pascal's Theorem.—If a hexagon be inscribed in a circle, the intersections of opposite sides
f. 0156 · p. 130viz., 1st and 4th, 2nd and 5th, 3rd and 6th, are collinear.
Let $ABCDEFA$ be the hexagon. The points $L, N, M$ are collinear.
Dem.—Join $EN$. Then the pencil $(N\,.\,FMCE) =$ the pencil $(C\,.\,FBDE)$, because they have a common transversal $EF$ (Cor. 3, Prop. 2). In like manner, the pencil $(A\,.\,FBDE) = (N\,.\,ALDE)$; but $(A\,.\,FBDE) = (C\,.\,FBDE)$ (Prop. 2, Cor. 4). Hence the pencils $(N\,.\,FMCE), (N\,.\,ALDE)$ are equal; and therefore (Cor. 2, Prop. 2) the points $L, N, M$ are collinear.
Cor. 1.—With six points on the circumference of a circle, sixty hexagons can be formed. For, starting with any point, say $A$, we could go from $A$ to one of the remaining points in five ways. Suppose we select $B$, then we could go from $B$ to a third point in four different ways, and so on; hence it is evident that we could join $A$ to another point, and that again to another, and so on, and finally return to $A$ in $5 \times 4 \times 3 \times 2 \times 1$ different ways. Hence we shall have that number of hexagons; but each is evidently counted twice, and we shall therefore have half the number, that is, sixty distinct hexagons.
Cor. 2.—Pascal’s Theorem holds for each of the sixty hexagons.
Cor. 3.—Pascal’s Theorem holds for six points,
f. 0157 · p. 131which are, three by three, on two lines. Thus, let the two triads of points be $A, E, C; D, B, F$, and the proof of the Proposition can be applied, word for word, except that the pencil $(A\,.\,FBDE)$ is equal to the pencil $(C\,.\,FBDE)$, for a different reason, viz., they have a common transversal.
Prop. 5.—If two equal pencils have a common ray, the intersections of the remaining three homologous pairs of rays are collinear.
Let the pencils be $(O\,.\,O'ABC), (O'\,.\,OABC)$, having the common ray $OO'$; then, if possible, let the line joining the points $A$ and $C$ intersect the rays $OB, O'B$ in different points $B', B''$; then, since the pencils are equal, the anharmonic ratio of the points $D, A, B', C$ equal the anharmonic ratio of the points $D, A, B'', C$, which is impossible. Hence the points $A, B, C$ must be collinear.
Cor. 1.—If $A, B, C; A', B', C'$ be two triads of points on two lines intersecting in $O$, and if the anharmonic ratio $(OABC) = (OA'B'C')$, the three lines $AA', BB', CC'$ are concurrent. For, let $AA', BB'$, intersect in $D$; join $CD$, intersecting $OA'$ in $E$; then the anharmonic ratio $(OA'B'E) = (OABC) = (OA'B'C')$ by hypothesis; therefore the point $E$ coincides with $C'$. Hence the Proposition is proved.
Cor. 2.—Desargues's Theorem.—If two $\Delta\text{s}$ $ABC, A'B'C'$ have lines joining corresponding vertices concurrent, the intersections of corresponding sides must be collinear. For, join $P$, the point of intersection of the sides $BC, B'C'$,
f. 0158 · p. 132to $O$, the centre of perspective; then each of the pencils $(A\,.\,PCA'B), (A'\,.\,PC'AB')$ is equal to the pencil $(O\,.\,PCAB)$; hence they are equal to one another, and they have the ray $AA'$ common. Hence the intersections of the three corresponding pairs of rays $AC, A'C', AP, A'P, AB, A'B'$, are collinear.
Cor. 3.—If two vertices of a variable $\Delta ABC$ move on fixed right lines $LM, LN$, and if the three sides pass through three fixed collinear points $O, P, Q$, the locus of the third vertex is a right line.
Let the side $AB$ pass through $O$, $BC$ through $P$, $CA$ through $Q$, and let $A'B'C'$ be another position of the $\Delta$; then the two $\Delta\text{s}$ $AA'Q, BB'Q$, have the lines joining their corresponding vertices concurrent; hence the intersections of the corresponding sides are collinear. Hence the Proposition is proved.
Prop. 6.—If on a right line $OX$ three pairs of points $A, A'; B, B'; C, C'$ be taken, such that the rectangles $OA \cdot OA', OB \cdot OB', OC \cdot OC'$, are each equal to a constant, say $k^2$, then the anharmonic ratio of any four points is equal to the anharmonic ratio of their four conjugates.
Dem.—Erect $OY$ at right $\angle\text{s}$ to $OX$, and make $OY = k$; join $AY, A'Y, BY, B'Y, CY, C'Y$. Now, by hypothesis, $OA \cdot OA' = OY^2$; $\therefore$ the $\odot$ described about the $\Delta AA'Y$ touches $OY$ at $Y$; $\therefore$ the $\angle OYA = OA'Y$. In like manner, the $\angle OYB = OB'Y$; hence the $\angle AYB$
f. 0159 · p. 133$= A'YB'$: similarly the $\angle BYC = B'YC'$, &c.; $\therefore$ the $\angle\text{s}$ of the pencil $(Y\,.\,ABCC') =$ the $\angle\text{s}$ of the pencil $(Y\,.\,A'B'C'C)$; and hence the anharmonic ratio of $(Y\,.\,ABCC')$ equal the anharmonic ratio of the pencil $(Y\,.\,A'B'C'C)$.
Cor. 1.—If the point $A$ moves towards $O$, the point $A'$ will move towards infinity.
Cor. 2.—The foregoing Demonstration will hold if some of the pairs of conjugate points be on the production of $OX$ in the negative direction; that is, to the left of $OY$, while others are to the right, or in the positive direction.
Cor. 3.—If the points $A, B, C$, &c., be on one side of $O$, say to the right, their corresponding points $A', B', C'$, &c., may lie on the other side; that is, to the left. In this case the $\Delta\text{s}$ $AYA', BYB'$, &c., are all right-angled at $Y$; and the general Proposition holds for this case also, namely, The anharmonic ratio of any four points is equal to the anharmonic ratio of their four conjugates.
Cor. 4.—The anharmonic ratio of any four collinear points is equal to the anharmonic ratio of the four points which are inverse to them, with respect to any circle whose centre is in the line of collinearity.
Def.—When two systems of three points each, such as $A, B, C; A', B', C'$, are collinear, and are so related that the anharmonic ratio of any four, which are not two couples of conjugate points, is equal to the anharmonic ratio of their four conjugates, the six points are said to be in involution. The point $O$ conjugate to the point at infinity is called the centre of the involution. Again, if we take two points $D, D'$, one at each side of $O$, such that $OD^2 = OD'^2 = k^2$, it is evident that each of these points is its own conjugate. Hence they have been called, by Townsend and Chasles, the double points of the involution. From these Definitions the following Propositions are evident:—
(1). Any pair of homologous points, such as $A, A'$, are harmonic conjugates to the double points $D, D'$.
(2). Three pairs of points which have a common pair of harmonic conjugates form a system in involution.
f. 0160 · p. 134(3). The two double points, and any two pairs of conjugate points, form a system in involution.
(4). Any line cutting three coaxal circles is cut in involution.
Def.—If a system of points in involution be joined to any point $P$ not on the line of collinearity of the points, the six joining lines will have the anharmonic ratio of the pencil formed by any four rays equal to the anharmonic ratio of the pencil formed by their four conjugate rays. Such a pencil is called a pencil in involution. The rays passing through the double points are called the double rays of the involution.
Prop. 7.—If four points be collinear, they belong to three systems in involution.
Dem.—Let the four points be $A, B, C, D$; upon $AB$ and $CD$, as diameters, describe circles; then any circle coaxal with these will intersect the line of collinearity of $A, B, C, D$ in a pair of points, which form an involution with the pairs $A, B; C, D$. Again, describe circles on the segments $AD, BC$, and circles coaxal with them will give us a second involution. Lastly, the circles described on $CA, BD$ will give us a third system. The central points of these systems will be the points where the radical axes of the coaxal systems intersect the line of collinearity of the points.
Prop. 8.—The following examples will illustrate the theory of involution:—
(1). Any right line cutting the sides and diagonals of a quadrilateral is cut in involution.
Dem.—Let $ABCD$ be the quadrilateral, $LL'$ the transversal intersecting the diagonals in the points $N, N'$. Join $AN', CN'$; then the anharmonic ratio of the pencil $(A\,.\,LMNN') = (A\,.\,DBON') = (C\,.\,DBON') = (C\,.\,M'L'ON) = (C\,.\,L'M'N'N)$.
f. 0161 · p. 135(2). A right line, cutting a circle and the sides of an inscribed quadrilateral, is cut in involution.
Dem.—Join $AR, AR', CR, CR'$; then the anharmonic ratio of the pencil $(A\,.\,LRMR') = (A\,.\,DRBR') = (C\,.\,DRBR') = (C\,.\,M'RL'R') = (C\,.\,L'R'M'R)$.
Cor.—The points $N, N'$ belong to the involution.
(3). If three chords of a circle be concurrent, their six points of intersection with the circle are in involution.
Let $AA', BB', CC'$ be the three chords intersecting in the point $O$. Join $AC, AC', AB', CB'$; then the anharmonic ratio $(A\,.\,CA'B'C') = (B'\,.\,CBAC') = (B'\,.\,C'ABC)$.
Cor.—The pencil formed by any six lines from the pairs of homologous points $A, A'; B, B'; C, C$, to any seventh point in the circumference is in involution.
Prop. 9.—If $O, O'$ be two fixed points on two given lines $OX, O'X'$, and if on $OX$ we take any system of points $A, B, C$, &c., and on $O'X'$ a corresponding system $A', B', C'$, &c., such that the rectangles $OA \cdot O'A' = OB \cdot O'B' = OC \cdot O'C'$, &c., equal constant, say $k^2$; then the anharmonic ratio of any four points on $OX$ equal the anharmonic ratio of their four corresponding points on $O'X'$.
This is evident by superposition of $O'X'$ on $OX$, so that the point $O'$ will coincide with $O$ (see Prop. 7); then the two ranges on $OX$ will form a system in involution.
Def.—Two systems of points on two lines, such that the anharmonic ratio of any four points on one line is equal
f. 0162 · p. 136to the anharmonic ratio of their four corresponding points on the other, are said to be homographic, and the lines are said to be homographically divided. The points $O, O'$ are called the centres of the systems.
Cor. 1.—The point $O$ on $OX$ is the point corresponding to infinity on $O'X'$; and the point $O'$ on $O'X'$ corresponds to infinity on $OX$.
Def.—If the line $O'X'$ be superimposed on $OX$, but so that the point $O'$ will not coincide with $O$, the two systems of points on $OX$ divide it homographically, and the points of one system which coincide with their homologous points of the other are called the double points of the homographic system.
Prop. 10.—Given three pairs of corresponding points of a line divided homographically, to find the double points.
Let $A, A'; B, B'; C, C'$, be the three pairs of corresponding points, and $O$ one of the required double points; then the conditions of the question give us the anharmonic ratio
$$ (OABC) = (OA'B'C'); $$
therefore
$$ \frac{OA \cdot BC}{OB \cdot AC} = \frac{OA' \cdot B'C'}{OB' \cdot A'C'}. $$
Hence
$$ \frac{OA \cdot OB'}{OA' \cdot OB} = \frac{B'C' \cdot AC}{BC \cdot A'C'} $$
equal constant, say $k^2$.
Now $OA \cdot OB', OA' \cdot OB$ are the squares of tangents drawn from $O$ to the circles described on the lines $AB'$ and $A'B$ as diameters; hence the ratio of these tangents is given; but if the ratio of tangents from a variable point to two fixed circles be given, the locus of the point is a circle coaxal with the given circles. Hence the point $O$ is given as one of the points of intersection of a fixed circle with $OX$, and these intersections are the two double points of the homographic system.
f. 0163 · p. 137If the three pairs of points be on a circle, the points of intersection of Pascal’s line with the circle will be the double points required. For (see fig., Prop. 5), let $D, B, F; A, E, C$, be the two triads of points, and let the Pascal’s line intersect the circle in the points $P$ and $Q$; then it is evident that the pencil $(A\,.\,PDBF) = (D\,.\,PAEC)$.
Cor.—If we invert the circle into a line, or vice versâ, the solution of either of the Problems we have given here will give the solution of the other.
Prop. 11.—We shall conclude this Section with the solution of a few Problems by means of the double points of homographic division.
(1). Being given two right lines $L, L'$, it is required to place between them a line $AA'$, which will subtend given angles $\Omega, \Omega'$ at two given points $P, P'$.
Solution.—Let us take arbitrarily any point $A$ on $L$. Join $PA, P'A$, and make the $\angle\text{s}$ $APA', APA''$, respectively equal to the two given $\angle\text{s}$ $\Omega, \Omega'$; then, when the point $A$ moves along the line $L$, the points $A', A''$ will form two homographic divisions on the line $L'$. The two double points of these divisions will give two solutions of the required Problem.
(2). Being given a polygon of any number of sides, and as many points taken arbitrarily, it is required to inscribe in the polygon another polygon whose sides will pass through the given points.
We shall solve this problem for the special case of a triangle; but it will be seen that the solution is perfectly general.
f. 0164 · p. 138Let $ABC$ be the given triangle; $P, Q, R$ the given points. Take on $AC$ any arbitrary point $D$. Join $PD$, intersecting $AB$ in $E$; then join $EQ$, intersecting $BC$ in $F$; lastly, join $FR$, intersecting $AC$ in $D'$; then the two points $D, D'$ will evidently form two homographic divisions on $AC$, the two double points of which will be vertices of two triangles satisfying the question.
(3). Being given three points $P, Q, R$, and two lines $L, L'$, it is required to describe a triangle $ABC$ having $C$ equal to a given angle, the vertices $A$ and $B$ on the given lines $L, L'$, and the sides passing through the given points.
Solution.—Through the point $R$ draw any line meeting the two lines $L, L'$ in the points $a, b$. Join $Pb$, and from $Q$ draw $Qa'$ making the required angle $C$ with $Pb$; the two points $a, a'$ will form two homographic divisions on $L$, the double points of which will give two solutions of the required question.
(4). To inscribe in a circle a triangle whose sides shall pass through three given points.
This is evidently solved like the preceding, by taking three false positions, and finding the double points of the two homographic systems of points.
(5). The problem of describing a circle touching three given circles can be solved at once by the method of taking
f. 0165 · p. 139three false positions, and finding double points, as follows:—
Let $A, B, C$ be the centres of the three given circles; $Z$ the required tangential circle; $\alpha, \beta, \gamma$ the points of contact: then the triangles $ABC$, $\alpha\beta\gamma$ are in perspective, the centre of $Z$ being their centre of perspective, and the axis of similitude of the three given circles being their axis of perspective. Let $A', B', C'$ be the three centres of similitude. Then take any three points $P, P', P''$ in the circle $A$; join them to the point $B'$, cutting the circle $C$ in the points $Q, Q', Q''$: again, join these points to $A'$, and let the joining lines cut the circle $B$ in the points $R, R', R''$: lastly, join $R, R', R''$ to $C'$, cutting the circle $A$ in the points $\pi, \pi', \pi''$; then $\alpha$ will be such that the anharmonic ratio $(\alpha P P' P'')$ will be equal to the anharmonic ratio $(\alpha \pi \pi' \pi'')$. Hence the problem is solved.
f. 0166 · p. 140Exercises.¶
The eight circles which touch three given circles may be divided into two tetrads—say $X, Y, Z, W; X', Y', Z', W'$—of which one is the inverse of the other with respect to the circle cutting the three given circles orthogonally.
Any two circles of the first tetrad, and the two corresponding circles of the second, have a common tangential circle.
Any three circles of either tetrad, and the non-corresponding circle of the other tetrad, have a common tangential circle.
Prove by means of the extension of Ptolemy's Theorem (the middle points of the sides being regarded as very small circles) that these point-circles, and the inscribed circle, or any of the escribed circles, have a common tangential circle.
The anharmonic ratios of the four points of contact of the “nine-points circle” with the inscribed and the escribed circles are respectively
$$ \frac{a^2 - b^2}{a^2 - c^2}, \qquad \frac{b^2 - c^2}{b^2 - a^2}, \qquad \frac{c^2 - a^2}{c^2 - b^2}. $$