Section III: Theory of Harmonic Section¶
John Casey — A Sequel to the First Six Books of the Elements of Euclid (5th ed., 1888), Book VI, pp. 87–94
f. 0113 · p. 87
Definition¶
Def.—If a line $AB$ be divided internally in the point $C$, and externally in the point $D$, so that the ratio $AC : CB = -\text{ratio } AD : DB$; the points $C$ and $D$ are called harmonic conjugates to the points $A, B$.
Since the segments $AC, CB$ are measured in the same direction, the ratio $AC : CB$ is positive; and $AD, DB$ being measured in opposite directions, their ratio is negative. This explains why we say $AC : CB = -AD : DB$. We shall, however, usually omit the sign minus, unless when there is special reason for retaining it.
Cor.—The centres of similitude of two given circles are harmonic conjugates, with respect to their centres.
Propositions¶
Prop. 1.—If $C$ and $D$ be harmonic conjugates to $A$ and $B$, and if $AB$ be bisected in $O$, then $OB$ is a geometric mean between $OC$ and $OD$.
Dem.—
$$ AC : CB :: AD : DB; $$
$$ \therefore \frac{AC - CB}{2} : \frac{AC + CB}{2} :: \frac{AD - DB}{2} : \frac{AD + DB}{2}; $$
or
$$ OC : OB :: OB : OD. $$
Hence $OB$ is a geometric mean between $OC$ and $OD$.
Prop. 2.—If $C$ and $D$ be harmonic conjugates to $A$ and $B$, the circles described on $AB$ and $CD$ as diameters intersect each other orthogonally.
Dem.—Let the $\odot\text{s}$ intersect in $P$, bisect $AB$ in $O$; join $OP$; then, by Prop. 2, we have $OC \cdot OD = OB^2 = OP^2$. Hence $OP$ is a tangent to the circle $CPD$, and therefore the $\odot\text{s}$ cut orthogonally.
f. 0114 · p. 88Cor. 1.—Any $\odot$ passing through the points $C$ and $D$ will be cut orthogonally by the $\odot$ described on $AB$ as diameter.
Cor. 2.—The points $C$ and $D$ are inverse points with respect to the $\odot$ described on $AB$ as diameter.
Def.—If $C$ and $D$ be harmonic conjugates to $A$ and $B$, $AB$ is called a harmonic mean between $AC$ and $AD$.
Observation.—This coincides with the algebraic Definition of harmonic mean.
For $AC, AB, AD$ being three magnitudes, we have
$$ AC : CB :: AD : BD; $$
therefore
$$ AC : AD :: CB : BD; $$
that is, the 1st is to the 3rd as the difference between the 1st and 2nd is to the difference between the 2nd and 3rd, which is the algebraic Definition.
Cor.—In the same way it can be seen that $DC$ is a harmonic mean between $DA$ and $DB$.
Prop. 3.—The Arithmetic mean is to the Geometric mean as the Geometric mean is to the Harmonic mean.
Dem.—Upon $AB$ as diameter describe a $\odot$; erect $EF$ at right angles to $AB$ through $C$; draw tangents to the $\odot$ at $E, F$, meeting in $D$; then, since the $\triangle OED$ is right-angled at $E$, and $EC$ is $\perp$ to $OD$, we have $OC \cdot OD = OE^2 = OB^2$. Hence, by Prop. 1, $C$ and $D$ are harmonic conjugates to $A$ and $B$. Again, from the same $\triangle$, we have $OD : DE :: DE : DC$; but $OD = \frac{1}{2}(DA + DB) =$ arithmetic mean between $DA$ and $DB$; and $DE$ is the geometric mean and $DC$ the harmonic mean between $DA$ and $DB$.
Cor.—The reciprocals of the three magnitudes $DA, DO, DB$ are respectively $DB, DC, DA$, with respect to $DE^2$; but $DA, DO, DB$ are in arithmetical progression.
f. 0115 · p. 89Hence the reciprocals of lines in arithmetical progression are in harmonical progression.
Prop. 4.—Any line cutting a circle, and passing through a fixed point, is cut harmonically by the circle, the point, and the polar of the point.
Let $D$ be the point, $EF$ its polar, $DGH$ a line cutting the $\odot$ in the points $G$ and $H$, and the polar of $D$ in the point $J$; then the points $J, D$ will be harmonic conjugates to $H$ and $G$.
Dem.—Let $O$ be the centre of the $\odot$; from $O$ let fall the $\perp OK$ on $HD$; then, since $K$ and $C$ are right $\angle\text{s}$, $OKJC$ is a quadrilateral in a $\odot$; $\therefore OD \cdot DC = KD \cdot DJ$; but $OD \cdot DC = DE^2$; $\therefore KD \cdot DJ = DE^2$. Hence $KD : DE :: DE : DJ$; and since $KD, DE$ are respectively the arithmetic mean and the geometric mean between $DG$ and $DH$, $DJ$ (Prop. 3) will be the harmonic mean between $DG$ and $DH$.
The following is the proof usually given of this Proposition:—Join $OH, OG, CH, CG$. Now $OD \cdot DC = DE^2 = DH \cdot DG$; $\therefore$ the quadrilateral $HOCG$ is inscribable in a $\odot$; $\therefore$ the angle $OCH = OGH$; and $DCG = OHD$; but $OGH = OHD$; $\therefore OCH = DCG$. Hence $HCJ = GCJ$; hence $CJ$ and $CD$ are the internal and external bisectors of the vertical angle $GCH$ of the triangle $GCH$; therefore the points $J$ and $D$ are harmonic conjugates to the points $H$ and $G$. Q.E.D.
Cor. 1.—If through a fixed point $D$ any line be drawn cutting the $\odot$ in the points $G$ and $H$, and if $DJ$ be a harmonic mean between $DG$ and $DH$, the locus of $J$ is the polar of $D$.
Cor. 2.—In the same case, if $DK$ be the arithmetic mean between $DG$ and $DH$, the locus of $K$ is a $\odot$, namely, the $\odot$ described on $OD$ as diameter, for the $\angle OKD$ is right.
f. 0116 · p. 90Prop. 5.—If $ABC$ be a triangle, $CE$ a line through the vertex parallel to the base $AB$; then any transversal through $D$, the middle of $AB$, will meet $CE$ in a point, which will be the harmonic conjugate of $D$, with respect to the points in which it meets the sides of the triangle.
Dem.—From the similar $\triangle\text{s}$ $FCE, FAD$ we have $EF : FD :: CE : AD$; but $AD = DB$; $\therefore EF : FD :: CE : DB$. Again, from the similar $\triangle\text{s}$ $CEG, BDG$, we have $CE : DB :: EG : GD$; therefore
$$ EF : FD :: EG : GD. \qquad \text{Q.E.D.} $$
Defs.—If we join the points $C, D$ (see last diagram), the system of four lines $CA, CD, CB, CE$ is called a harmonic pencil; each of the four lines is called a ray; the point $C$ is called the vertex of the pencil; the alternate rays $CD, CE$ are said to be harmonic conjugates with respect to the rays $CA, CB$. We shall denote such a pencil by the notation $(C\,.\,FDGE)$, where $C$ is the vertex; $CF, CD, CG, CE$ the rays.
Prop. 6.—If a line $AB$ be cut harmonically in $C$ and $D$, and a harmonic pencil $(O\,.\,ABCD)$ formed by joining the points $A, B, C, D$ to any point $O$; then, if through $C$, a parallel to $OD$, the ray conjugate to $OC$ be drawn, meeting $OA, OB$ in $G$ and $H$, $GH$ will be bisected in $C$.
Dem.—
$$ OD : CH :: DB : BC; $$
and
$$ OD : GC :: DA : AC; $$
but $DB : BC :: DA : AC$; $\therefore OD : CH :: OD : GC$. Hence $GC = CH$.
f. 0117 · p. 91Cor.—Any transversal $A'B'C'D'$ cutting a harmonic pencil is cut harmonically.
For, through $C'$ draw $G'H' \parallel$ to $GH$; then, by Prop. 3, Section I., $G'C' : C'H' :: GC : CH$; $\therefore G'C' = C'H'$. Hence $A'B'C'D'$ is cut harmonically.
Let $ABCD$ be the quadrilateral whose two sides [AD], [BC] meet in F; then the line $FO$, and the third diagonal [FE], form a pair of conjugate rays with $FA$ and $FB$.
Dem.—Through $O$ draw $OH \parallel$ to $AD$; meet $BC$ in $G$, and the third diagonal in $H$. Then $OG = GH$ (Prop. 8, Section I.). Hence the pencil $(F\,.\,AOBE)$ is harmonic. In like manner the pencil $(E\,.\,AODF)$ is harmonic.
Prop. 8.—If four collinear points form a harmonic system, their four polars with respect to any circle form a harmonic pencil.
Let $A, C, B, D$ be the four points, $P$ the pole of their line of collinearity with respect to the $\odot X$; let
f. 0118 · p. 92$O$ be the centre of $X$. Join $OA, OB, OC, OD$, and let fall the $\perp\text{s}$ $PA', PB', PC', PD'$ on these lines; then, by Prop. 25, Section I., Book III., $PA', PB', PC', PD'$ are the polars of the points $A, B, C, D$; and since the angles at $A', C', B', D'$ are right, the $\odot$ described on $OP$ as diameter will pass through these points; and since the system $A, B, C, D$ is harmonic, the pencil $(O\,.\,ABCD)$ is harmonic; but the angles between the rays $OA, OB, OC, OD$ are respectively equal to the angles between the rays $PA', PB', PC', PD'$ (III., xxi.). Hence the pencil $(P\,.\,A'B'C'D')$ is harmonic.
Def.—Four points in a circle which connect with any fifth point in the circumference by four lines, forming a harmonic pencil, are called a harmonic system of points on the circle.
Prop. 9.—If from any point two tangents be drawn to a circle, the points of contact and the points of intersection of any secant from the same point form a harmonic system of points.
Dem.—Let $Q$ be the point, $QA, QB$ tangents, $QCD$ the secant; take any point $P$ in the circumference of the $\odot$, and join $PA, PC, PB, PD$; then, since $AB$ is the polar of $Q$, the points $E, Q$ are harmonic conjugates to $C$ and $D$; $\therefore$ the pencil $(A\,.\,QCED)$ is harmonic; but the pencil $(P\,.\,ACBD)$ is equal to the pencil $(A\,.\,QCED)$, for the angles between the rays of one equal the angles between the rays of the other; therefore the pencil $(P\,.\,ACBD)$ is harmonic. Hence $A, C, B, D$ form a harmonic system of points.
Cor. 1.—If four points on a $\odot$ form a harmonic system, the line joining either pair of conjugates passes through the pole of the line joining the other pair.
Cor. 2.—If the angular points of a quadrilateral inscribed in a $\odot$ form a harmonic system, the rectangle
f. 0119 · p. 93contained by one pair of opposite sides is equal to the rectangle contained by the other pair.
Prop. 10.—If through any point $O$ two lines be drawn cutting a circle in four points, then joining these points both directly and transversely; and if the direct lines meet in $P$ and the transverse lines meet in $Q$, the line $PQ$ will be the polar of the point $O$.
Dem.—Join $OP$; then the pencil $(P\,.\,OAEB)$ is harmonic (Prop. 7); $\therefore$ the points $O, E$ are harmonic conjugates to the points $A, B$. Hence the polar of $O$ passes through $E$ (Prop. 4). In like manner, the polar of $O$ passes through $F$; $\therefore$ the line $PQ$, which passes through the points $E$ and $F$, is the polar of $O$. Q.E.D.
Cor. 1.—If we join the points $O$ and $Q$, it may be proved in like manner that $OQ$ is the polar of $P$.
Cor. 2.—Since $PQ$ is the polar of $O$, and $OQ$ the polar of $P$, then (Cor. 1, Prop. 16, Section I., Book III.) $OP$ is the polar of $Q$.
Def.—Triangles such as $OPQ$, which possess the property that each side is the polar of the opposite angular point with respect to a given circle, are called self-conjugate triangles with respect to the circle. Again, if we
f. 0120 · p. 94consider the four points $A, B, C, D$, they are joined by three pairs of lines, which intersect in the three points $O, P, Q$ respectively; then, on account of the harmonic properties of the quadrilateral $ABCD$ and the triangle $OPQ$, I propose to call $OPQ$ the harmonic triangle of the quadrilateral.
Prop. 11.—If a quadrilateral be inscribed in a circle, and at its angular points four tangents be drawn, the six points of intersection of these four tangents lie in pairs on the sides of the harmonic triangle of the inscribed quadrilateral.
Dem.—Let the tangents at $A$ and $B$ meet in $K$ (see fig., last Prop.); then the polar of the point $K$ passes through $O$. Hence the polar of $O$ passes through $K$; therefore the point $K$ lies on $PQ$. In like manner, the tangents at $C$ and $D$ meet on $PQ$. Hence the Proposition is proved.
Cor. 1.—Let the tangents at $B$ and $C$ meet in $L$, at $C$ and $D$ in $M$, at $A$ and $D$ in $N$; then the quadrilateral $KLMN$ will have the lines $KM$ ($PQ$) and $LN$ ($OQ$) as diagonals; therefore the point $Q$ is the intersection of its diagonals. Hence we have the following theorem:—If a quadrilateral be inscribed in a circle, and tangents be drawn at its angular points, forming a circumscribed quadrilateral, the diagonals of the two quadrilaterals are concurrent, and form a harmonic pencil.
Cor. 2.—The tangents at the points $B$ and $D$ meet on $OP$, and so do the tangents at the points $A$ and $C$. Hence the line $OP$ is the third diagonal of the quadrilateral $KLMN$; and the extremities of the third diagonal are the poles of the lines $BD, AC$. Now, since the lines $BD, AC$ are harmonic conjugates to the lines $QP, QO$, the poles of these four lines form a harmonic system of points. Hence we have the following theorem:—If tangents be drawn at the angular points of an inscribed quadrilateral, forming a circumscribed quadrilateral, the third diagonals of these two quadrilaterals are coincident, and the extremities of one are harmonic conjugates to the extremities of the other.