Book VI, Section I Summary: Concurrent Lines & Transversals

Mathematical Synthesis of Casey’s Book VI, Section I (pp. 67–81)

1. Architectural Overview

Section I marks the fundamental transition in Casey’s Sequel from metric Euclidean geometry to projective and transversal invariants:

  • Ceva vs. Menelaus Duality (Props. 2 & 4): Both theorems evaluate the cyclic product of ratios $\frac{BA'}{A'C} \cdot \frac{CB'}{B'A} \cdot \frac{AC'}{C'B}$ along the sides of $\triangle ABC$: $+1$ characterizes concurrency of three lines from the vertices (Ceva, 1678), while $-1$ characterizes collinearity of three points on the sides (Menelaus).

  • Parallels & Harmonic Proportions (Prop. 3): Concurrent transversals cut parallel lines into proportional segments; perpendicular distances from points on transversals maintain constant ratios.

  • Circumradius Area Formula (Prop. 5): The rectangle contained by two sides equals the altitude times the circumdiameter ($bc = 2pR$), yielding the invariant area identity $\Delta = \frac{abc}{4R}$.

  • Inscribed Polygon Perpendicular Product (Prop. 6): For any inscribed $2n$-gon, the product of perpendiculars from any circumference point to the odd sides equals the product to the even sides ($\prod \perp_{\text{odd}} = \prod \perp_{\text{even}}$).

  • Circle of Apollonius (Prop. 7): The locus of a point whose distances from two fixed points have a constant ratio is a circle whose diameter is bounded by the internal and external harmonic division points.

  • Perspective Triangles (Prop. 14): When three triangles are pairwise in perspective with the same centre of homology, their three axes of homology are concurrent.


2. Structured Decompositions

Ceva’s Theorem (Prop. 2)

  • Given: Triangle $\triangle ABC$ and concurrent cevians $AA', BB', CC'$ meeting at $O$.

  • Construct: Base lines $AO, BO, CO$ meeting opposite sides in $A', B', C'$.

  • Demonstrate: By Prop. 1, triangles on common base $AO$ satisfy $\frac{BA'}{A'C} = \frac{\triangle AOB}{\triangle AOC}$. Cyclically permuting vertices gives $\frac{CB'}{B'A} = \frac{\triangle BOC}{\triangle BOA}$ and $\frac{AC'}{C'B} = \frac{\triangle AOC}{\triangle BOC}$. Multiplying the three ratios cancels the triangle areas identically:

    $$ \frac{BA'}{A'C} \cdot \frac{CB'}{B'A} \cdot \frac{AC'}{C'B} = \frac{\triangle AOB}{\triangle AOC} \cdot \frac{\triangle BOC}{\triangle BOA} \cdot \frac{\triangle AOC}{\triangle BOC} \equiv +1. $$

  • Invariants: Concurrency of medians ($1 \cdot 1 \cdot 1 = 1$), internal angle bisectors ($\frac{c}{b} \cdot \frac{a}{c} \cdot \frac{b}{a} = 1$), altitudes, symmedians, Gergonne lines, and Nagel lines all follow as direct corollaries.

Menelaus’s Theorem (Prop. 4)

  • Given: Triangle $\triangle ABC$ cut by transversal line $L$ in points $A', B', C'$ on sides $BC, CA, AB$.

  • Construct: Drop perpendiculars $p', p'', p'''$ from vertices $A, B, C$ onto transversal $L$.

  • Demonstrate: Right triangles give similar ratio identities $\frac{AB'}{B'C} = \frac{p'}{p'''}$, $\frac{BC'}{C'A} = \frac{p''}{p'}$, and $\frac{CA'}{A'B} = \frac{p'''}{p''}$. Taking directed segments introduces one or three negative signs, giving product $-1$. Conversely, if product is $-1$, the points are collinear.

  • Invariants: External bisector collinearity (Cor. 2); Monge’s axes of similitude (Section II); Desargues’s axis of homology (Section VI).


3. Canonical Heronian Ledger on $\triangle ABC$ $(15, 13, 14)$

Verified in geometor.casey.invariants:

Exact Rational Transversal Invariants for $(15, 13, 14)$

Theorem / Object

Formulation

Exact Value on $(15, 13, 14)$

Circumradius $R$

$R = \frac{abc}{4\Delta}$

$\frac{15 \cdot 13 \cdot 14}{4 \cdot 84} = \frac{65}{8}$

Inradius $r$

$r = \frac{\Delta}{s}$

$\frac{84}{21} = 4$

Area Identity

$\Delta = \frac{abc}{4R} = rs$

$84$

Medians Ceva Ratio

$\frac{BA'}{A'C} \cdot \frac{CB'}{B'A} \cdot \frac{AC'}{C'B}$

$1 \cdot 1 \cdot 1 = +1$

Bisectors Ceva Ratio

$\frac{c}{b} \cdot \frac{a}{c} \cdot \frac{b}{a}$

$\frac{14}{13} \cdot \frac{15}{14} \cdot \frac{13}{15} = +1$

External Bisectors Menelaus

$\left(-\frac{c}{b}\right) \cdot \left(\frac{a}{c}\right) \cdot \left(\frac{b}{a}\right)$

$-1$