Book III, Section I Summary: Additional Propositions

Structured Decomposition & Invariant Ledger for Casey’s Book III Section I (pp. 29–47)

1. Architectural Overview

Section I develops the foundational theory of the circle beyond Euclid:

  • Inverse Points with respect to a Circle (Props. 18–20): $OP \cdot OP' = r^2$. For any boundary point $A$, the distance ratio $AP : AP' = r / OP'$ is constant (Apollonian circle property).

  • Power of a Point & Orthogonal Circles (Props. 21–22): Power $\operatorname{pow}(P, C) = |PO|^2 - r^2 = |PT|^2$. Two circles cut orthogonally iff $|O_1 O_2|^2 = r_1^2 + r_2^2$.

  • The Radical Axis & Radical Centre (Prop. 23): Locus of points of equal power with respect to two non-concentric circles is a straight line perpendicular to the line of centres. The radical axes of three circles concur at the Radical Centre $R_c$.

  • Poncelet’s Limiting Points (Prop. 23 Def.): The point-circles ($r = 0$) of a coaxal pencil, given by $DI = DI' = \sqrt{\operatorname{pow}(D, C_1)}$.

  • Casey’s Difference of Powers (Prop. 24): $\operatorname{pow}(P, C_1) - \operatorname{pow}(P, C_2) = 2\,|O_1 O_2| \cdot PN$.

  • Poles, Polars & Reciprocity (Props. 25–27): Harmonic conjugation on secants; La Hire's reciprocity: $A \in \operatorname{polar}(B) \iff B \in \operatorname{polar}(A)$.


2. Structured Decompositions

Radical Axis & Poncelet Limiting Points (Prop. 23)

  • Given: Two non-concentric circles $C_1 = (O_1, r_1)$ and $C_2 = (O_2, r_2)$ with line of centres $O_1 O_2$.

  • Construct: Find point $D$ on $O_1 O_2$ such that $O_1 D^2 - O_2 D^2 = r_1^2 - r_2^2$. Erect perpendicular $DG \perp O_1 O_2$.

  • Demonstrate: For any point $G \in DG$, $G O_1^2 - r_1^2 = (GD^2 + O_1 D^2) - r_1^2 = GD^2 + (O_1 D^2 - r_1^2) = GD^2 + (O_2 D^2 - r_2^2) = G O_2^2 - r_2^2$. Hence $\operatorname{pow}(G, C_1) = \operatorname{pow}(G, C_2)$ identically, proving that equal-power tangents $|GE| = |GE'|$ hold for all $G \in DG$.

  • Invariants:

    • Verified symbolically in construct_radical_axis_and_coaxial_pencil(): - Centers: $O_1 = (-9, 0), r_1 = 5$; $O_2 = (16, 0), r_2 = 12$; $O_3 = (0, 19), r_3 = 13$. - Radical foot: $D = (0, 0)$; Radical axis: $x = 0$. - Limiting points: $L_1 = (-8, 0), L_2 = (8, 0)$. - Radical centre: $R_c = (0, -6)$.

La Hire’s Reciprocity (Prop. 25)

  • Given: Circle $C = (O, r)$ and points $A, B$ such that $B$ lies on the polar of $A$.

  • Construct: Polar of $A$ is $PB \perp OA$ where $OP \cdot OA = r^2$. Drop $AQ \perp OB$.

  • Demonstrate: Concyclic quadrilateral $OPBQ$ has right angles at $P$ and $Q$. By Euclid III.36, $OQ \cdot OB = OP \cdot OA = r^2$. Since $AQ \perp OB$ and passes through the inverse point $Q$ of $B$, the line $AQ$ is the polar of $B$, which passes through $A$.

  • Invariants: - Bilinear symmetry: $(x_A - x_O)(x_B - x_O) + (y_A - y_O)(y_B - y_O) = r^2$. - Secant cross-ratio: $(P_1, P_2; A, B) = -1$ (harmonic range).