Book I, Section I Summary: Additional Propositions

Structured Decomposition & Invariant Ledger for Casey’s Book I Section I (pp. 1–16)

1. Architectural Overview

Section I extends Euclid’s Book I by deriving the classical triangle concurrencies and barycentric theory using strictly elementary methods (congruence and parallelograms, without appealing to Book III circle theorems or Book VI ratios):

  • Parallelogram & Midline Theorems (Props. 1–3): Bisection of diagonals; midline parallel to base and equal to half the base ($DE = \frac{1}{2} BC$).

  • Locus of Vertex under Difference of Squares (Props. 9–10): The locus of vertices of triangles on a given base with given difference of squares of sides is a straight line perpendicular to the base.

  • Concurrency of Perpendiculars / The Orthocentre (Prop. 10 Cor. 1): Proved via the anticomplementary triangle $\triangle A'B'C'$ whose perpendicular bisectors coincide with the altitudes of $\triangle ABC$.

  • Concurrency of Medians / The Centroid (Prop. 11): Proved via similar midline triangles; the centroid $G = X(2)$ trisects each median in ratio $2:1$.

  • Centres of Mean Position (Props. 16–17): Synthetic construction of weighted barycentres $\bar{P} = (\sum m_i P_i)/(\sum m_i)$, establishing the foundation for barycentric coordinates.

  • Variational Extremes (Props. 20–22): Isoperimetric properties of triangles and cyclic polygons.


2. Structured Decompositions

Orthocentre Concurrency (Prop. 10 Cor. 1)

  • Given: Arbitrary triangle $\triangle ABC$ with altitudes $A D_a, B D_b, C D_c$.

  • Construct: Anticomplementary triangle $\triangle A'B'C'$ by drawing lines through $A, B, C$ parallel to $BC, CA, AB$ respectively.

  • Demonstrate: Quadrilaterals $ABCB'$ and $ABA'C$ are parallelograms; hence $B'A = BC = AC'$, making $A$ the midpoint of $B'C'$. Similarly $B$ and $C$ are midpoints of $C'A'$ and $A'B'$. Since $A D_a \perp BC \parallel B'C'$, the altitude $A D_a$ is the perpendicular bisector of $B'C'$. By Euclid I, the perpendicular bisectors of $\triangle A'B'C'$ concur at a single point $H$.

  • Invariants: - $AH = 2\,O M_a$, $BH = 2\,O M_b$, $CH = 2\,O M_c$ (where $O$ is circumcentre and $M_a, M_b, M_c$ side midpoints). - Exact rational locus on Heronian $\triangle ABC$ $(15, 13, 14)$: $H = \left(5, \frac{15}{4}\right)$.

Medians Concurrency & Trisection (Prop. 11)

  • Given: Triangle $\triangle ABC$ with midpoints $M_a, M_b, M_c$ on sides $BC, CA, AB$.

  • Construct: Join $M_a M_b$; let medians $A M_a$ and $B M_b$ meet at $G$.

  • Demonstrate: $M_a M_b \parallel AB$ and $M_a M_b = \frac{1}{2} AB$ (Props. 2, 3). The vertically opposite triangles $\triangle ABG$ and $\triangle M_a M_b G$ are equiangular; hence $AG = 2\,G M_a$ and $BG = 2\,G M_b$. The third median $C M_c$ likewise cuts $A M_a$ at the point trisecting it, so all three concur at $G$.

  • Invariants: - Barycentric weights: $G = \frac{1}{3} A + \frac{1}{3} B + \frac{1}{3} C$. - Exact rational locus on Heronian $\triangle ABC$ $(15, 13, 14)$: $G = \left(\frac{19}{3}, 4\right)$.


3. Canonical Heronian Ledger on $\triangle ABC$ $(15, 13, 14)$

Verified symbolically in construct_euler_nine_point() on $A = (0, 0), B = (14, 0), C = (5, 12)$:

Exact Rational Invariants for Book I Section I

Geometric Object

Symbol

Value on $(15, 13, 14)$

Side lengths $(a, b, c)$

$a, b, c$

$a = 15, \; b = 13, \; c = 14$

Area & Semiperimeter

$\Delta, s$

$\Delta = 84, \; s = 21$

Centroid

$G = X(2)$

$\left(\frac{19}{3}, 4\right)$

Orthocentre

$H = X(4)$

$\left(5, \frac{15}{4}\right)$

Circumcentre

$O = X(3)$

$\left(7, \frac{33}{8}\right)$

Altitude feet $(D_a, D_b, D_c)$

$D_a, D_b, D_c$

$\left(\frac{224}{25}, \frac{168}{25}\right), \; \left(\frac{350}{169}, \frac{840}{169}\right), \; (5, 0)$

Side midpoints $(M_a, M_b, M_c)$

$M_a, M_b, M_c$

$\left(\frac{19}{2}, 6\right), \; \left(\frac{5}{2}, 6\right), \; (7, 0)$