Posterior Analytics II.19 — Critical Commentary & Notes¶
Historical-Mathematical (Heath) & Scholastic-Noetic (Hoenen) Apparatus · Bekker 99b15–100b17
I. Mathematical-Historical Commentary (Secundum Heath & Euclidem)¶
Heath (Thirteen Books, Vol. I, p. 322; Mathematics in Aristotle, pp. 61–68) highlights 85b37–86a3 as our earliest explicit Greek attestation of the general theorem extending Elements I.32: that the exterior angles of any rectilinear figure (triangle, quadrilateral, etc.), when the sides are produced in order, are together equal to four right angles (4R). Proclus later preserved this corollary in his commentary on Euclid I.32.
In 87a35–37, Aristotle records the Pythagorean-Academic definition of the arithmetical unit as ‘substance without position’ (οὐσία ἄθετος) and the geometrical point as ‘substance having position’ (οὐσία θετός). As Heath notes (Vol. I, p. 155), Euclid deliberately replaced this ontological definition in Elements I, Def. 1 (Σημεῖόν ἐστιν, οὗ μέρος οὐθέν — ‘A point is that which has no part’) to keep geometry independent of Pythagorean monadic ontology while retaining indivisibility.
II. Scholastic-Noetic Commentary (Secundum Hoenen, Thomam & Paciolum)¶
For Hoenen (De Noetica Geometriae, Caput III, n. 1, p. 71; Caput V, pp. 159–189), Posterior Analytics I.31 (87b35–39) and II.19 (99b15–100b17) form a single indivisible arch. In Caput III, Hoenen deploys 87b35—‘even if it were possible to perceive by sense that the triangle has its angles equal to two right angles, we should still seek a demonstration’—to demolish John Stuart Mill’s and Hermann von Helmholtz’s geometric empiricism. Sensory measurement always halts before a threshold of exactitude (limen exactitudinis); it can at best report approximate physical coincidence here and now, never strict equality (= 2R) or universal necessity.
Conversely, in Caput V, Hoenen reads Posterior Analytics II.19 alongside Aquinas (In Anal. Post. II, lect. 20) to show that epagōgē is the exact opposite of Humean enumerative induction. Because mathematical form exists individuated in sensible and imaginative extension, a single clear imaginative presentation suffices—once sensible irrelevancies are abstracted—for nous to apprehend the universal nexus immediately and infallibly.
III. Locus-by-Locus Philological & Geometrical Notes¶
100a12–100b17 — The Simile of the Routed Army & Nous as Archē Archēs
Just as one soldier halting in a rout brings a second and then the whole phalanx back to order, one retained percept stabilizes the universal concept in the soul until nous grasps the immediate principle.
IV. Sister-Corpus Citations Indexed in This Chapter¶
Bekker Locus |
Treatise & Chapter |
Sister Repos |
Cited Locations (Volume, Page / Folio & Display) |
|---|---|---|---|
Analytica Posteriora II.19 |
|
hoenen (de_noetica_geometriae, Caput V, p. 186): |