Book of Lemmas (Liber Assumptorum)

Kitāb al-Maʾkhūdhāt / Liber Assumptorum — Archimedes, tr. Thābit ibn Qurra, ed. Borelli & Ecchellensis (ecchellensis-borelli:1661), T. L. Heath (heath:1897, pp. 301–318)

Note

Edition Track (English): Complete 15-proposition planar treatise from heath:1897 (pp. 301–318, archimedes:liber-assumptorum), verified page-by-page across all 18 rendered 300 DPI pages of Heath (1897) and collated with Heiberg's Teubner text (heiberg:1881, Vol. II, pp. 426–445). Switch tracks above for the Summary or Notes.

Propositions 1–3: Tangent Circles, Semicircle Tangents & Chord Ratios

[Folio Heath (1897), pp. 301–304 · Heiberg II, 426–430 | p. 301]
  • Proposition 1 (Homothetic Chords of Tangent Circles): If two circles touch at A, and if CD, EF be parallel diameters in them, then ADF is a straight line (and similarly ACE when tangent externally). Proved by parallel radii and alternate angles (Eucl. I. 29, Eucl. VI. 32).

  • Proposition 2: Let AB be the diameter of a semicircle, and let the tangents to it at B and at any other point D on it meet in T. If now DE be drawn perpendicular to AB, and if AT, DE meet in F, then .

  • Proposition 3: Let P be any point on a segment of a circle whose base is AB, and let PN be perpendicular to AB. Take D on AB so that . If PQ be an arc equal to the arc PA, and BQ be joined, then BQ, BD are equal (and in the half-angle chord geometry later utilized by Ptolemy).


Propositions 4–6: The Arbelos (Ἄρβηλος) & Twin Circles

[Folio Heath (1897), pp. 304–309 · Heiberg II, 430–436 | p. 304]
Proposition 4 (Area of the Arbelos). If AB be the diameter of a semicircle and N any point on AB, and if semicircles be described within the first semicircle and having AN, NB as diameters respectively, the figure included between the circumferences of the three semicircles is ‘what Archimedes called ἄρβηλος’ (shoemaker’s knife); and its area is equal to the circle on PN as diameter, where PN is perpendicular to AB and meets the original semicircle in P.

Proof: By Eucl. III. 31 and Eucl. VI. 8, , so . Since circles and semicircles are to one another as the squares on their diameters (Eucl. XII. 2), the outer semicircle on AB equals the sum of the two inner semicircles on AN, NB together with twice the semicircle (i.e. one whole circle) on PN. Subtracting the two inner semicircles leaves the arbelos equal to the circle on PN!

Book of Lemmas (Props. 4–5): The Arbelos & Archimedes' Twin Circles A C B D W₁ W₂ Prop. 4: Area(Arbelos) = π · (CD/2)² Prop. 5: Twin Radii r₁ = r₂ = (r_AC · r_CB) / (r_AC + r_CB)
Book of Lemmas, Propositions 4 & 5 — The Arbelos (AB = AC + CB), Tangent Altitude CD, and Equal Twin Circles
Proposition 5 (Archimedes’ Twin Circles). Let AB be the diameter of a semicircle, C any point on AB, and CD perpendicular to it, and let semicircles be described within the first semicircle and having AC, CB as diameters. Then if two circles be drawn touching CD on different sides and each touching two of the semicircles, the circles so drawn will be equal (Archimedes' Twin Circles).

Proof: Let one circle touch CD at E, the outer semicircle AB at F, and the inner semicircle AC at G, and let its diameter EH be parallel to AB. By Proposition 1, FHG and BFA and AGC align homothetically, yielding ! That is:

\[AB \cdot EH = AC \cdot CB \implies EH = \frac{AC \cdot CB}{AB}.\]

Because the expression is symmetric in AC and CB, the second circle inscribed on the opposite side of CD (touching CD, semicircle AB, and semicircle CB) has diameter , strictly equal to EH!

[Folio Heath (1897), pp. 307–309 · Heiberg II, 433–436 | p. 307]
Proposition 6 (Maximum Inscribed Circle in the Arbelos). Let AB, the diameter of a semicircle, be divided at C so that [or in any given ratio ]. Describe semicircles within the first semicircle and on AC, CB as diameters, and suppose a circle drawn touching all three semicircles. If GH be the diameter of this circle, to find the relation between GH and AB.
Book of Lemmas (Prop. 6): Circle Inscribed in the Arbelos & Pappus Chain Seed A O₁ C O₂ B P AC : CB = 3 : 2 ⇒ d_circle : AB = 6 : 19 General Ratio: d / AB = (r₁ r₂) / (r₁² + r₁ r₂ + r₂²)
Book of Lemmas, Proposition 6 — Circle Tangent to All Three Semicircles of the Arbelos (GH : AB = 6 : 19 for 3 : 2) & Pappus Chain

By repeated application of Proposition 1 through the three points of contact, Archimedes proves that for , , and in general if , then:

\[GH : AB = \lambda : (1 + \lambda + \lambda^2) = (AC \cdot CB) : (AC^2 + AC \cdot CB + CB^2).\]

Furthermore, the height of the centre of this inscribed circle above AB equals its own diameter GH—the base case () of the celebrated ‘ancient proposition’ preserved by Pappus (pappus:synagoge:iv, IV.14: for the -th circle in the infinite tangent chain)!


Propositions 7–13: Neusis Angle Trisection & Orthogonal-Chord Quadrance

[Folio Heath (1897), pp. 309–315 · Heiberg II, 436–442 | p. 309]
  • Proposition 7: If circles be circumscribed about and inscribed in a square, the circumscribed circle is double of the inscribed circle ().

Proposition 8 (Neusis Trisection of the Angle). If AB be any chord of a circle whose centre is O, and if AB be produced to C so that BC is equal to the radius (neusis insertion meeting the diameter DOE produced at C), and if CO meet the circle in D and be produced to meet the circle a second time in E, the arc AE will be equal to three times the arc BD.
Book of Lemmas (Prop. 8): Archimedes' Neusis Angle Trisection C F D E B A θ 3θ Neusis insertion CB = r (= DB = DA) ⇒ ∠BCD = 1/3 · ∠ADE
Book of Lemmas, Proposition 8 — Archimedes' Marked-Straightedge (Neusis) Angle Trisection (BC = OA = OB implies Angle AOE = 3 Angle BOD)

Proof: Draw chord EF parallel to AB, and join OB, OF. Since , the triangle OBC is isosceles (Eucl. I. 5), so . By exterior angles (Eucl. I. 32), . Since and , , and by alternate angles (actually via ): subtends and equals ! Directly: in isosceles triangleOAB, ; then in triangleOAC, exterior . Thus !

  • Proposition 9: Intersecting chords perpendicular/secant arc-sum lemma.

  • Proposition 10: Secant and tangent segments from an external point (connected to Apollonius’s Tangencies).

  • Proposition 11 (Orthogonal Chords Quadrance Invariant):

    If two chords AB, CD in a circle intersect at right angles in a point O, not being the centre, then:

    \[AO^2 + BO^2 + CO^2 + DO^2 = (\text{diameter})^2 = 4 R^2.\]

    Proved cleanly via diameter CE perpendicular to AB (or through centre), Eucl. III. 31, and Eucl. I. 47—a pure Rational Trigonometry quadrance identity (geometor:wildberger)!

  • Proposition 12: Polar-orthocenter property of two tangents to a semicircle (TRperpAB).

  • Proposition 13: Equal chord segments cut off by perpendiculars onto a diameter ().


Propositions 14 & 15: The Salinon & Pentagon/Decagon Golden Ratio

[Folio Heath (1897), pp. 316–318 · Heiberg II, 442–445 | p. 316]
Proposition 14 (The Salinon / ‘Salt-Cellar’). Let ACB be a semicircle on AB as diameter, and let AD, BE be equal lengths measured along AB from A, B respectively. On AD, BE as diameters describe semicircles on the side towards C, and on DE as diameter a semicircle on the opposite side. Let the perpendicular to AB through O, the centre of the first semicircle, meet the opposite semicircles in C, F respectively. Then shall the area of the figure bounded by the circumferences of all the semicircles (‘which Archimedes calls a σάλινον’) be equal to the area of the circle whose diameter is CF.
Book of Lemmas (Prop. 14): The Salinon (Salt-Cellar) Quadrature A D O E B C F Area(Salinon) = Area(Circle on Diameter CF) = π · (CF / 2)²
Book of Lemmas, Proposition 14 — Archimedes' Salinon Bounded by Four Semicircles Equals the Circle on Symmetry Axis CF

Proof: Because , is the diameter of each lateral semicircle, and , we have . Squaring gives . Converting diameters-squared into semicircles via Eucl. XII. 2 shows that !

Proposition 15 (Pentagon, Decagon & the Golden Section). Let AB be the diameter of a circle, AC a side of an inscribed regular pentagon, D the middle point of the arc AC. Join CD and produce it to meet BA produced in E; join AC, DB meeting in F, and draw FM perpendicular to AB. Then EM is equal to the radius of the circle (and EC is cut in extreme and mean ratio , Eucl. XIII. 9!).

Proved from inscribed pentagon/decagon angles ( and of two right angles) and Euclid’s golden-section theorem (Eucl. XIII. 9: the side of the hexagon and the side of the decagon inscribed in the same circle, when added together, cut the whole segment in extreme and mean ratio ).