Reconstructed Analytic Works

The Lost Treatises of the Domain of Analysis (Τόπος ἀναλυόμενος) — Apollonius of Perga (Pappus Synagoge VII)

Beyond the Conics, Apollonius of Perga authored six major two-book treatises forming the core of the ancient Domain of Analysis (Τόπος ἀναλυόμενος) preserved for posterity in Book VII of Pappus of Alexandria's Mathematical Collection (Synagoge, ed. Hultsch 1877; geometor/pappus). Five of these treatises were lost in Greek, while one (Cutting Off of a Ratio) survived in Arabic (Halley 1706).

Summary of the Treatises

Treatise

Books

Survival / Restoration

Core Geometric Problem & GEOMETOR Link

Cutting Off of a Ratio (De Sectione Rationis)

2

Extant in Arabic (Halley 1706)

Line through O cutting given ratio on two fixed lines (pappus)

Cutting Off of an Area (De Sectione Spatii)

2

Pappus VII lemmas; restored Halley 1706

Line through O cutting given rectangle on two fixed lines (pappus)

Determinate Section (De Sectione Determinata)

2

Pappus VII (66 lemmas); Snell / Simson

1D cross-ratio / involution (pappus)

Tangencies (De Tactionibus, epaphai)

2

Pappus VII; Viète 1600

10 contact cases PPP–CCC (up to 8 tangent circles); ETC X(181)

Inclinations (De Inclinationibus, neusis)

2

Pappus VII; Ghetaldi / Horsley

Plane-constructible verging insertions (rhombus, semicircle, two lines)

Plane Loci (Loca Plana)

2

Pappus VII; Fermat (1636) / Simson (1749)

Circle of Apollonius (); ETC X(15), X(16)

Sections

Lost Tangencies (Pappus VII): The Problem of Apollonius (CCC — All 8 Tangent Circles) C₁ C₂ C₃ Given C₁, C₂, C₃ (bold): 1 externally tangent (green) · 1 enclosing (gold) · 6 mixed-contact pairs (blue/rose)

1. On Tangencies (Περὶ ἐπαφῶν) — The Problem of Apollonius (CCC)

Pappus summarizes the famous ten contact problems of Apollonius’s two-book treatise On Tangencies: given any three geometric elements in a plane—each being a Point (`P`), a Straight Line (`L`), or a Circle (`C`)—construct by straightedge and compass a circle tangent to all three (PPP, PPL, PPC, PLL, PLC, PCC, LLL, LLC, LCC, and CCC). While PPP (IV.5) and LLL (IV.4) belong to Euclid's Elements, the crowning tenth problem `CCC` (Three Given Circles) admits up to eight distinct tangent circles:

Plane Loci II: Locus PA : PB = k A B I₁ I₂ M P PA : PB = AI₁ : I₁B = AI₂ : BI₂ = k (∠I₁PI₂ = 90°) ETC Bridge: Three Apollonius Circles ⇒ X(15), X(16) A B C X(15) X(16) a·PA = b·PB = c·PC at Isodynamic Points X(15), X(16)

2. Plane Loci (Τόποι ἐπίπεδοι) — The Circle of Apollonius

Locus of Apollonius (Plane Loci II). Whereas the locus of a point P whose distances to two fixed points AB are equal () is the perpendicular bisector of AB, the locus of P whose distances bear any given unequal ratio () is a circle (the Circle of Apollonius), whose diameter HmathrminHmathrmex divides AB internally and externally in the ratio ([VI.3]).

3. The Remaining Four Analytic Treatises in Pappus VII

Cutting Off of a Ratio (Περὶ λόγου ἀποτομῆς, 2 Books — extant in Arabic, ed. Halley 1706): Through a given point draw a straight line cutting off segments on two given lines (measured from given base points) bearing a prescribed ratio—exhaustively classified across 21 loci and diorismoi.